TRAI supports net neutrality, says services should be free of bias

29 November, 2017, 01:00 | Author: Regina Lloyd
  • Deseret News        Letter to the Editor

The Trai's recommendations comes at a time when there is a debate raging over Net neutrality globally.

The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India's headquarters in New Delhi.

Industry stakeholders Tuesday gave a mixed reaction to the telecom regulator Trai's recommendations on Net Neutrality (NN), with some terming the recommendations as "progressive" and "pragmatic" and others finding them "a bit simplistic in the light of increasing complexity in the economics of Internet". As expected, the regulator has backed the core principles of NetNeutrality, stating that no service provider can discriminate or put a restriction or interfere in the treatment of content.

"The Authority reiterates that the use of the internet should be facilitated in such a manner that it advances the free speech rights of citizens, by ensuring plurality and diversity of views, opinions, and ideas", TRAI said in its net neutrality recommendations.

These licensing terms should provide explicit restrictions on any sort of discrimination in access based on the content the consumer chooses to access.

FCC Chairman Ajit Pai, who was appointed by President Donald Trump earlier this year, called the current rules, which were passed by the Obama administration in 2015, "heavy-handed", and said the FCC would stop micro-managing internet in the US. He says that huge things are going to happen on the internet and it is important for India to keep it open.




It also said the scope of the proposed principles on non-discriminatory treatment apply specifically to "Internet Access Services", which are generally available to the public.

May 30, 2016: TRAI's pre-consultation on net neutrality. However, the specialized services may be offered by the service provider only if they are not usable as a replacement of Internet access services.

What is the broader thought process that went behind Trai's recommendations on net neutrality?

Specialised services are essentially those services that have extremely critical quality requirement, which are not really internet related. Essentially, what we are saying is if telecom service providers have charged for data, then they should just do data relaying.

TRAI also notes that "DoT may establish a multi-stakeholder body with framework for collaborative mechanism" for "monitoring and enforcement" of net neutrality recommendations.

"The service providers should be restricted from entering into any arrangement, agreement or contract, by whatever name called, with any person, natural or legal, that has the effect of discriminatory treatment based on content, sender or receiver, protocols, or user equipment". He should have the freedom to exercise traffic management practices.

Recommended:

  • LeBron James Calls David Fizdale 'Fall Guy' After Firing; Dwyane Wade: 'WTF'

    LeBron James Calls David Fizdale 'Fall Guy' After Firing; Dwyane Wade: 'WTF'

    Memphis is mired in an eight-game losing streak and owns a 7-12 mark this season after advancing to the playoffs in 2016-17. Fizdale was fined $30,000 by the National Basketball Association for a rant over officiating after a loss in Game 2.
    Ivanka Trump lobbies for women at entrepreneurship summit in India

    Ivanka Trump lobbies for women at entrepreneurship summit in India

    Her India visit has made headlines but questions have been raised if she is the right person to talk about empowering women. This facility would provide access to capital, networks, and mentorship for women in developing countries, she said.
    RK Nagar by-election on December 21, counting on December 24

    RK Nagar by-election on December 21, counting on December 24

    The DMK meanwhile had named Marudhi Ganesh as their candidate, and the BJP named composer Gangai Amaran to fight for them. The Election Commission gave back the two-leaves symbol to EPS-OPS faction on November 23.
  • Trump Makes 'Pocahontas' Slur While Honoring Native Americans

    Trump Makes 'Pocahontas' Slur While Honoring Native Americans

    Immediately after the event, White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders defended Trump's deplorable racial slur. President Donald Trump has used an event honoring Native American veterans to take a shot at Democratic Sen.
    Army called in to secure capital

    Army called in to secure capital

    Video from the scene Saturday showed law enforcement forces carrying sticks and firing tear gas and rubber bullets at protesters. A mob attacked former Interior Minister Nisar Ali Khan's house in Rawalpindi and broke the main gate of his house.
    U.S.  welcomes Saudi move to address humanitarian crisis in Yemen

    U.S. welcomes Saudi move to address humanitarian crisis in Yemen

    Since Nov. 6, the United Nations and global aid agencies have repeatedly urged the coalition to lift the Yemen blockade. Seven million Yemenis are completely dependent on humanitarian supplies for their survival, according to the UN.
  • Julio Jones shreds Bucs secondary puts NFC on notice

    Julio Jones shreds Bucs secondary puts NFC on notice

    However, Fitzpatrick and the Buccaneers still weren't able to do enough to survive on the road unfortunately. Ryan was 26 of 35 for 317 yards , while Sanu remained flawless in his career when throwing the ball.
    Trump accuses CNN of 'representing United States  poorly'

    Trump accuses CNN of 'representing United States poorly'

    The victor of this imaginary contest would receive the "fake news trophy" that could be proudly displayed among other awards. This is not the first time Comey seems to have tacitly thrown his two cents in on the president's actions .
    Black Friday is Alive and Well at the Millcreek Mall

    Black Friday is Alive and Well at the Millcreek Mall

    The federation said they would release the weekend's shopping results on November 28, the day after Cyber Monday. One survey found almost half of respondents planned to skip Black Friday and Cyber Monday altogether this year.
  • Black Friday Was A Big Day for Gun Sales

    Black Friday Was A Big Day for Gun Sales

    While many Americans were buying furniture and appliances on Black Friday, a record number were also seeking clearance to purchase guns.
    Dan Mullen Targeted By Gators

    Dan Mullen Targeted By Gators

    He was a part of two national championship teams in 2006 and 2008, when he served as Urban Meyer's offensive coordinator. Foley and Mullen did not have a strong relationship during his time as Florida's coordinator.
    United Kingdom  study once again suggests coffee is quite good for you

    United Kingdom study once again suggests coffee is quite good for you

    However, doctors warn that these findings aren't enough to advise those who aren't drinking coffee already to pick up the habit. They wrote: 'Coffee is highly consumed worldwide and could have positive health benefits, especially in chronic liver disease.


Popular

TIME says Trump is 'incorrect' on 'Person of the Year' award process
High-profile Twitter users parodied Trump's tweet to discuss all the hypothetical awards they had also turned down. He says he told the magazine that "probably" isn't good enough, and he would pass on the opportunity.

Christmas tree farms open in Eugene
Once the tree is ready, place it trunk facing forward onto the top the vehicle and attach it with ratchet straps or strong rope. Sanity won out and we got a 6-foot tree. "Typically most people end up realizing real trees are more traditional", Absher said.

Sacked Vincenzo Montella Hopes Gennaro Gattuso Does Well At Milan
Montella was sacked on Monday and replaced with Primavera boss Gattuso following a bad start to the Serie A campaign. They drew 0-0 with Torino at home on Sunday and have lost six of their 14 top-flight matches this season.

Watch India vs Sri Lanka LIVE Cricket Match on Hotstar
Pujara, on the other hand, continued to notch runs together with utter ease and little problems. The hosts were 185 for one at tea, still trailing Sri Lanka by 20 runs in their first innings.

Manchester City defeats Huddersfield
Sterling's victor won Man City the three points and move eight points clear of their nearest rivals, Manchester United . We had chances and we were able to win and we are top of the group.

Everybody Is Talking About What Happened Between Klopp And Mane
City are unbeaten this season and can restore their eight-point lead at the top in the league when they visit Huddersfield Town on Sunday.

President Trump hits the golf course with Tiger Woods, Dustin Johnson
Trump has come under fire from critics who bemoan his pace of almost 700 rounds of golf if he finishes two terms in office. Trump hit up the golf course to spend some time hitting a couple balls with Tiger Woods and Dustin Johnson earlier today.

Bullet-riddled body of man working for Army found
The locals found the body lying in pool of blood inside Wothmula Nad area of Keegam, after which they informed the police. National Conference leader and former chief minister Omar Abdullah also took to Twitter to condemn the incident.

Twelve Dead in Georgia Hotel Fire, Say Officials
In a later post he offered his condolences the families and promised an investigation to find the fire's causes. Participants in the Miss Georgia beauty pageant were among the guests of the hostel at the moment.

London Subway Station Evacuated After Reports Of Shots Fired
The panic erupted on one of the busiest shopping days, in a jittery city that has been hit by four violent attacks this year. The station was evacuated and panicked shoppers and commuters sheltered in shops and offices in the area.